REQUEST
FOR
PROPOSAL
For the Design of a
MOTORIZED AUTOMATIC SPHEROID
STORAGE DEVICE
The Department of Engineering
Baylor University
Waco, Texas 76798
Fall 1996
I. STATEMENT
OF WORK
Qualified
engineering design teams are invited to submit a technical proposal for the
design of a Motorized Automatic Spheroid Storage device to the Department of
Engineering at Baylor University, hereafter referred to as the owner. Upon owner approval of the proposed design,
the successful engineering team, hereafter referred to as the design
team, shall build, test, and evaluate a prototype device. The design team shall then furnish a formal
written report and demonstrate the performance of the prototype device to the
owner.
The design, construction, testing, and reporting of
the Motorized Automatic Spheroid Storage device, hereafter referred to as the device,
is a requirement for completion of Engineering 3380 - Engineering Design I at
Baylor University for the fall semester 1996.
II. SPECIFICATION
1. Scope
The
design team shall design, construct, test, and evaluate a multi-function
device. The device shall move two ping pong balls and one golf ball from a
recessed platform into a receiving box. The design objectives are to move the
balls over the greatest distance as quickly and reliably as possible.
2. Design Requirements
2.1 Design Criteria
The
design team shall design the device to meet or exceed all of the criteria
listed below.
2.1.a. The device
shall meet or exceed all criteria as contained in “ASME Student Design
Competition Design Problem - 1996/1997,” appendix A, and all subsequent “Update
Bulletins” published by the American Society of Mechanical Engineers.
2.1.b. The device
shall not be dangerous to personnel, destructive to Baylor property, or
otherwise inappropriate for operation in a classroom at Baylor University as
judged by the owners. Special design
attention is required to ensure that the device will not function in a manner
that could damage the desktop, carpet, or other building furnishings.
2.1.c. The owners
may choose to keep the device including all parts needed for assembly and
operation for future instructional purposes.
2.2 Design Documentation
The
design team shall document the project by use of manuscripts, calculations and
drafted drawings. All documents shall be one-sided on either had-written green
engineering paper (National Form 42-381 or equal) or laser-printed on 8.5x11”
or 11x17” white paper. A formal engineering report is required with drawings
and spreadsheet cost figures. Formal oral progress reports are required using
at least one overhead transparency and other visual aids as necessary.
3. Safety Requirements
The
design team shall conduct all construction and testing with safety as the
primary consideration. Failure to observe departmental workplace rules will
lead to penalties in performance evaluation.
4. Manufacturing Requirements
4.1 Materials Procurement
The
owners shall supply the design team a basic set of tools for construction. Any
additional tools and supplies desired by the design team shall be acquired at
the design team's expense.
4.2 Identification
a. Nameplates
The
design team shall provide nameplate identification on both the storage
container and the prototype device, which includes a minimum of the design team
name, device name, and team members names in at least 12 point lettering.
b. Warning
Labels
The
design team shall affix clearly visible warning labels to all components of the
device that may pose a safety hazard to operators or observers of the device.
4.3 Clean Up
Cleanliness
in the workplace is expected at all times and in all work areas. Failure to observe departmental workplace
rules will lead to penalties in performance evaluation. The
design team shall clean all work areas with each use.
5. Test Requirements
The
entire design team shall test the assembled device during the construction phase
to ensure the device is fully operational and within the design specifications
of this document. The design team shall
assemble and operate the device during the required final acceptance test.
III. CONTRACT SCHEDULE
The following is the schedule of required submittals:
Date Submittal
Thursday, Sept. 12 CONCEPTUAL
DESIGN
Thursday, Sept. 19 PRELIMINARY
DESIGN I
Thursday, Sept. 26 PRELIMINARY
DESIGN II
Thursday, Oct. 10 PRELIMINARY
DESIGN III
Thursday, Oct. 17 PRELIMINARY
DESIGN IV
Thursday, Oct. 24 FINAL
DESIGN
Friday, Oct. 31 QUALIFICATION
TEST
Thursday, Nov. 7 REVISION
PLAN
Thursday, Nov. 14 FINAL
ACCEPTANCE TEST
Wednesday, Nov. 20 FINAL
ENGINEERING REPORT
All project submittals are due on the scheduled date
at the start of scheduled class time and shall be delivered to the owner in
room 109 of the Rogers Engineering and Computer Science Building at that
time. Incomplete or unsatisfactory
submittals shall be resubmitted and will be assessed an owner-specified
penalty.
IV. PROJECT DELIVERABLES
The
design team shall furnish the following project submittals in accordance with
the above contract schedule. The design team should maintain a copy of all
submittals for their own use.
1. Conceptual Design
1.1 Conceptual Plans
Free
hand plan and elevation sketches of the complete device showing the general
arrangement of the device, including estimates of basic dimensions of overall
height, width, and depth. The sketches
shall clearly identify each of the subsystems.
1.2 Conceptual Specifications
A
brief written description of each of the device subsystems and of the device
sequence of operation. Each subsystem
shall be given a subsystem title by the design team and the narrative shall
include the elapsed time estimate, if appropriate, for each subsystem.
2. Preliminary Design I
2.1 Motor Torque-Speed Requirement
An
estimate of the operating torque and speed requirement of the motor based on
conceptual plans and specifications. Brief qualitative and quantitative (if
possible) analysis justifying this estimate.
2.2 Motor Test
A
plan for testing the motor to determine experimentally if motor torque-speed
requirement can be met. Shall include brief written procedure, sketches of test
set-up, and data sheets for recording results.
3. Preliminary Design II
3.1 Assembly Sketches
Orthographic
assembly sketch(es) of each subsystem.
The drawings shall be drafted using a straight edge and standard
engineering drafting and lettering practices, including the use of a standard
drawing template and title block, overall dimensions, and notes. All drawings shall be submitted on
engineering paper and shall be accomplished in pencil with appropriate line
weights.
4. Preliminary Design III
4.1 Subsystem Test
At
the preliminary design II progress meeting, the design team and the owners
shall identify one subsystem for hardware demonstration at the preliminary
design III progress meeting.
5. Preliminary Design IV
5.1 Assembly CAD Drawings
Orthographic
assembly drawings of each subsystem.
The drawings shall be drafted using a computer, including the use of a
standard drawing template and title block, overall dimensions, and notes. All drawings submitted shall be
laser-printed on white paper.
6. Final Design
6.1 Drawing Package
A
final construction drawing package consisting of a cover sheet, a drawing
index, plan and elevation views of
device, subsystem assembly drawings, detail drawings, and a cost estimate shall
be submitted by each design team. The
detail drawings to be submitted will be specified to the design team by the
owners.
6.2 Sequence of Operation
A
revised written sequence of operation for the device. This sequence is frozen when the final design is submitted and
will provide the standard of performance for the compliance test.
7. Qualification Test
7.1 Prototype Device
A
fully-functional working prototype of the device.
8. Revision Plan
8.1 Revision Plan
A
detailed plan to modify the device according to a clearly stated set of performance
criteria. The plan shall include the performance criteria, justification for
modication, revised assembly and detail drawings as necessary, construction
plan for executing the modifications, and a list of potential negative outcomes
resulting from the modifications. The construction plan shall include a cost
estimate and a time schedule for the modifications.
8.2 Operator’s Manual
The
operator’s manual includes instructions for assembling, operating, and
troubleshooting the device. These
written instructions shall be supported by appropriate sketches.
9. Final Acceptance Test
9.1 Prototype Device
A
fully-functional working prototype of the device which shall perform according
to all applicable performance criteria as well as the qualification test
device. Better performance in some or all performance criteria is highly
desirable.
9.2 Isometric Drawing
A
computer-drafted isometric drawing of the device.
9.3 Poster Documentation
A
poster to include copies of only the following items: team name, device name,
team members’ names, date, device plan and elevation drawings, isometric
drawing, operating and calibration instructions, and assembly drawings (if
desired).
10. Final Engineering Report
The
design team shall submit a written engineering report which shall include the
items listed below as attachments.
10.1 As-built Drawing Package and Cost Figures
The
complete as-built drawing package, including the revised as-built construction
drawings and cost figures.
10.2 Operators Manual
As
specified in section 8.2.
10.3 Request for Proposal
One
copy of this document.
V. GENERAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE CLAUSES
Each
member of the design team shall thoroughly document individual contributions to
the project in a design notebook.
VI. OWNER-FURNISHED MATERIAL
The
equipment and materials listed below will be made available to the design team
by the owner. The design team shall assume the responsibility of normal
diligence and care in handling and maintenance of owner-furnished equipment. Other materials, equipment, and shop
assistance may be provided at the owner's discretion as per written request by
the design team.
1. Tool Kit.
2. Platform
Box.
3. Receiving/Storage
Box.
VII. POINT OF CONTACT
The
design team shall submit all requests for clarification, waiver, or additional
information associated with the design, construction, or testing of the device
in writing. Requests shall adhere to the format shown in appendix B.
Appendix A
ASME
Student Design Competition Design Problem - 1996/1997
Appendix B
Design
Team Written Communications to Owners
DATE:
TO: Drs. Newberry and Williams
FROM: (Design Team Name)
SUBJECT: MASS Device
consisting
of the following: Tool box, padlock, glue sticks, coping saw tape measurer,
flat leg divider, hack saw, glue gun, utility knife, diagonal pliers, six piece
wrench comb. set, 6" pliers, diagonal pliers, 1/2" steel countersink,
tubing cutter, combination square, miter box and saw, six piece screwdriver
set, 6" adjustable wrench, 36" straight-edge aluminum rule, wood
drills, hammer, multi-purpose snips, wire cutter/stripper, 8" slip joint
pliers, pop rivet kit, and nail and wood screw assortments